As
time passes and actors age, the job of portraying popular characters
naturally changes hands. This may also be due, to changes in
ownership of the film rights, or a new creative direction. Whatever
the case, as long as there is a demand for a character to appear in
film, different versions of that character will continue to accrue.
Eventually, people will have a debate regarding which performance is
the definitive one.
Classic
Movie Trailers - Goldfinger (1964)
So,
which James Bond is the best one? No matter how you look at it,
that's a subjective question, that will produce a subjective answer.
However, you can look at certain facts that lead to those opinions.
For example, your choice for the best Bond might also be the first
performer, that you saw play that role.
That
actor doesn't necessarily, have to be the first one to portray the
character. He may just be the first that you had seen. So, there is a
familiarity and an attachment and an immediate association, that
other actors will never replace. If a significant amount of time has
passed since that interpretation, nostalgia plays a role as well.
It's
also possible, that you've read the books that have inspired the
movies. In that case, you may choose your definitive version based on
how closely the actor looks, to the image that you have created in
your head. That image, would be based on the book's description of
the character and possibly the illustrations. Alternatively, it may
be that the actor's behavior in the role, closely matches how the
character would behave, according to the evidence present in those
books.
That
actually leads to another point. Your favorite James Bond, may have
nothing to do with the actor whatsoever. It may have a lot more to
do, with the quality of the production that they're in. Quality is,
of course, subjective, and interestingly, your idea of quality may
be, the interpretation farthest away from the original source
material.
Your
favorite Bond, or Batman, or Holmes, or Superman, is your favorite
for objective reasons, which shape your subjective opinion. No single
portrayal, is undoubtedly the clear winner, so doubt persists and
debates return obstinately. As fans, we are extremely fortunate
because of this. No answer is right, or wrong, so the discussion and
the fun never ends.
@ChannelSeals
http://youtu.be/94UpZMvUvEk